I know very well that my music taste is pretty obscure. But how obscure? Without any accepted standards or parameteters there is a high risk of ending up in endless discussions about obscurity in general and if x is really more obscure than y in particular. Fortunately, there is now a legitimit and scientific way to answer the question and settle all disputes, namely the Obscurometer (see link here). The Obscurometer measures the obscurity of an artist from 0 (no obscurity) to 100 percent (total obscurity). You can read how the overall obscurity level is computed in more detail on the Obscurometer website. The average artist obscurity according to the Obscurometer is 93,2 percent. This is a very high figure, but bear in mind that there are nearly 370 000 artists in the database (of which some are known only by the artists themselves). Some statistics so you get the general idea: Lady Gaga 10,9 percent, Taylor Swift 28,5 percent and Garth Brooks 50,9 percent. I put all artists in the 42 articles on the website in the Obscurometer and here is some basic statistics: average mean 85,6 percent, first quartile 79,6 percent, median 86,9 percent and third quartile 91,2 percent. The result is fairly as expected. The most obscure artists in the article series are American Sinner (98,5), Pushin Rope (97,5) and The Blackthorns (96,7) percent. The least obscure artists in the article series are 16 Horsepower (65,6), Murder by Death (65,8) and The Handsome Family (68,6) percent. After studied the result I have three general conclusions:
1) Obscurity is a good thing
"Whenever people agree with me I always feel I must be wrong." - Oscar Wilde
2) Obscurity is desirable
In my opinion, the higher obscurity level the better. Obscurity level should not be less than 66,6 percent. And never under 50 percent.
3) Obscurity is, however, not an end in itself
“Money may not buy happiness, but I'd rather cry in a Jaguar than on a bus.” - Françoise Sagan
Below is a complete list of overall obscurity level (all artists in 42 articles).
ARTIST/BAND |
Obscurity (%) |
WEST |
|
The Denver Gentlemen |
86,6 |
Pushin Rope |
97,5 |
Tarantella |
83,3 |
Munly & the Lee Lewis Harlots |
85.3 |
The Handsome Family |
68,6 |
16 Horsepower |
65,6 |
Wovenhand |
80,2 |
The Builders and The Butchers |
77,2 |
Palodine |
91,4 |
SOUTH |
|
Sons of Perdition |
86,1 |
Blackgrass |
93,3 |
Baptist Generals |
95,0 |
Highlonesome |
90,9 |
American Sinner |
98,5 |
The Shivers |
n/a |
Pinebox Serenade |
89,7 |
Creech Holler |
89,0 |
The Victor Mourning |
96,4 |
Antic Clay |
86,5 |
Myssouri |
86,9 |
Trailer Bride |
90,8 |
Jim White |
72,6 |
Bonnie 'Prince' Billy |
73,3 |
Vic Chesnutt |
70,1 |
MIDWEST |
|
Blanche |
78,9 |
The Blackthorns |
96,7 |
Souled American |
91,2 |
The Roe Family Singers |
96,3 |
Strawfoot |
86,2 |
Christian Williams |
88,8 |
Those Poor Bastards |
79,6 |
.357 String Band |
90,4 |
Murder by Death |
65,8 |
Puerto Muerto |
85,4 |
Slackeye Slim |
91.2 |
NORTHEAST |
|
Fire on Fire |
87,1 |
Rex |
87,1 |
Filthy Still |
96,4 |
Reverend Glasseye |
86,0 |
O'Death |
77,5 |
CANADA |
|
Uncle Sinner |
91,2 |
Elliott Brood |
77,7 |
Note: Data was retrieved from Obscurometer 2014-09-01.