About the list: As you might have realized by now: all the genres, subgenres and labels are not mutually exclusive. In fact, very far from that. It's a jumble without precedent and more a question of not misplacing than placing. Here's a list of essential gothic americana... or something like that.

   

No

 Cover Album Artist

Notes

 

 

1

1401739331 65

 

 

Hilarious Death Blues

(2007)

 

 

Antic Clay

"A slow dark ride across the scorched hide of America. Think Johnny Cash riding a skeletal mule to Hell. Not without moments of beauty and hope, however." This rare double album is, of course, a class act.

 

 

2

 

1401739331 65

 

 

Consider the Birds

(2004)

 

 

Wovenhand

David Eugene Edwards went "all in" with 16 Horsepower. Wovenhand has a subdued and introvert sound and expression. "The world will bow / The knees will be broken for those who don't know how". This album is really  strange and enigmatic.

 

 

3

 

1401739331 65

 

 

 

Low Estate

(1999)

 

 

 

 

16 Horsepower

16 Horsepower is the mother of (almost) all “gothic country” bands. Many people regard their second album as their finest hour. With "Low Estate" they raised the bar for "gothic americana" once and for all.

 

 

 

4

 

1401739331 65

 

 

 Thin & Pale

(2009)

 

 

 The Mountain Apple Epidemic 

Many people will raise their eyebrows when they find this obscure and rare album placed as number four. Nevertheless, it's a correct and well-deserved placement. Trust me, just listen to "A Golden Veil" if you have any doubts.   

 

 

5

 

1401739331 65

 

 

Broken Hymns, Limbs And Skin

(2008)

 

 

O'death

This is a very intense album with nasal and high-pitch vocals. It's also dark as the night, like the song "Home": "I'd light a fire beside the skin and dig a hole for bones to lay / Find a sacred resting place where the pecking hens won’t harm the eyes”.

 

 

6

 

1401739331 65

 

 

 

Let the River Take Them Home

(2008)

 

 

 

Pinebox Serenade 

Pinebox Serenade mixes country with rock without becoming despicable country rock. It's sounds too good to be true, but it's actually true. "Let the River Take Them Home" is a splendid and very rare album.      

 

  

7

1401739331 65

 

 

 Garden of Deceit

(2008)

 

 

 

Palodine 

 
The music has been described as "goth moodiness, high and lonesome twang and a cinematic sensibility". "Garden Of Deceit" is Palodine's darkest and best album. Don’t let the husband-and-wife soft duo stereotype fool you. This is hard stuff, indeed.

 

 

8

 

1401739331 65

 

 

In Bocca Al Lupo

(2006)

 

 

Murder by Death

"Sometimes you walk the line / And sometimes it walks you". Very well formulated. This is "gothic americana" on the verge to despicable indie rock. In Bocca Al Lupo [appr. good luck] is the third album by "Murder by Death". 

 

 

9

1401739331 65

 

 

Salvation Is a Deep Dark Well

(2009)

 

 

The Builders and the Butchers

Another great "gothic americana" band on the verge to indie rock. TBATB would be just another ordinary indie band, if it weren’t for their weird, brooding and gothic sound. They found the perfect solfège on their second album. 

 

 

10

1401739331 65

 

 

Idle Hands

(2007)

 

 

 The Maledictions

Evocative country noir from The Maledictions. If it weren't for a few weak songs towards the end of the album, "Idle Hands" would have a higher position on the list, despite the cut-throat competition. This is their second and best album.