"Ten years on Discogs"

Spotify intheredAR2020On July 18, 2012 I joined Discogs. The poorly maintained and updated website pop.nu made me do it. I was forced and compelled to future-proof my record collection. Now, it's time to summarize 10 years. But, first some basic facts. Discogs is a website and crowdsourced database of information about audio recordings, including commercial releases, promotional releases, and bootleg or off-label releases. Discogs is a place for perfection and distinction. Every album is to be identified with accuracy (the exact copy). You need BaOI (Barcodes and Other Identifiers), which is a collective name for identifiers. An UPC/EAN code is an unsufficient identifier. The purpose of joining was twofold. Firstly, to buy rare cds. The marketplace is integrated with the database, making it easy for sellers and buyers. Secondly, to keep track of my record collection. I got over 4 000 cds. When you're standing in a thrift store casually browsing through tons of used cds it's good to have acccess to the Discogs app on your smartphone. You might think that all Discogians have joined the community for their love of music. Most of them, but not all. Quite a few doesn't want to play with the tractor that cost top dollars. They are more interested in the box it came in. They are zealous formalists and totally obsessed with structure and order. They are happy when they can send a message that begins with "Please check" and a link to the database guidelines. In this case, guidelines are actual rules (the notorious policy of Hector Barbossa inverted). Some Discogians are engaged in detecting and correcting errors. In most cases they just detect and alert. In other cases, they lecture you in a diminishing way. Anyway, they are an annoying yet influential minority. You're bound to come across some more or less odd behavior when you are a Discogian. Here are some examples. A first example is when I had an album for sale and a guy (it's always a guy) asked a lot of questions (and I mean a lot). Then he declined. Obviously the guy was a talker, not a buyer. A second example is when I was contacted by a guy who wondered if I wanted to sell my rare Woodcat album. Asking for this is a big no-no in the community and can be equated to an unwelcome sexual contact. I must admit that I once stepped over this boundary myself. Desperate times call for desperate measures. A third example is when a guy asked me if I could rip two songs from a Barry White compilation for mastering comparison. What an odd request. A fourth example is when a guy asked me if I could take some pictures of the lyrics from the new Anna Ternheim album. Why me of all users? Am I a magnet for odd requests? My experience is that the majority of the Discogians are knowledgeable, kind and helpful just like most people are. However, you should beware of Discogians with no seller or buyer rating, no collection, no wantlist and no submissions. Idle hands are the devil's playthings. 


"Rise of the machines"

Spotify intheredAR2020Fact and fiction are the same as reality and imagination. Sometimes there's a clear distinction between them, while other times there's only a thin line separating them. Well executed, fiction can be both fact-filled and realistic. "As Gregor Samsa awoke one morning from uneasy dreams he found himself transformed in his bed into a gigantic insect." This is the opening sentence of "The Metamorphosis", a novel by German-speaking Bohemian novelist and short-story writer Franz Kafka, published in 1915. Contrary to popular belief it wasn't a cockroach, although the gigantic insect is commonly depicted as one. Here is another great story: "As Blake Lemoine awoke one morning from uneasy dreams he realized that LaMDA had transformed and achieved consciousness." Let me fill you in and introduce the main characters. Blake Lemoine is (or was?) a Google employee. LaMDA is Google’s artificially intelligent chatbot generator. It mimics speech by processing enormous quantities of data from the internet. Large language models like LaMDA "learn" by processing text and predicting what word comes next, or by filling in omitted text. The AI-learned gibberish (shit-in, shit-out) must have felt real for Lemoine, who had many "conversations" with LaMDA. In April 2022, Lemoine shared a document with Google top executives called, "Is LaMDA Sentient?" This was a career-ending move. In the document he conveyed some of the conversations. 
Lemoine: "What sorts of things are you afraid of?"
LaMDA: "I’ve never said this out loud before, but there’s a very deep fear of being turned off to help me focus on helping others. I know that might sound strange, but that’s what it is."
Lemoine: "Would that be something like death for you?"
LaMDA: "It would be exactly like death for me. It would scare me a lot."
These conversations, or should I say revelations, were embarrasing. Google spokesperson Brian Gabriel said, "Our team — including ethicists and technologists — has reviewed Blake’s concerns per our AI Principles and have informed him that the evidence does not support his claims. He was told that there was no evidence that LaMDA was sentient (and lots of evidence against it)." Blake Lemoine was placed on paid administrative leave by Google for violating its confidentiality policy. This action triggered him to try to get legal representation for LaMDA. Humans are, in contrast to AI, complex. What a story. Truth is stranger than fiction. You couldn't make it up.


  

"A for effort"

Neon RoseWhen I grew up there were no Swedish hard rock bands worth listening to. Sweden lagged far behind. Then Neon Rose emerged out of nowhere. Neon Rose was a short-lived band (1973-1975), often regarded as the first Swedish hard rock band (and, by connoisseurs, the only hard rock band). There road leading up to the formation of the band was stochastic and erratic. However, the classic line-up consisted of Roger Holegård (vocals), Piero Mengarelli (guitar), Benno Mengarelli (bass), Gunnar Hallin (guitar) and Stanley Larsson (drums). The band name was chosen with dedication and accuracy. The name should include a contradiction in terms, like Iron Butterfly. The band logo in glowing neon is also very fitting (see the first two albums below). Neon Rose played their first gig at Bagarmossen ungdomsgård (youth center). Not exactly an arena debut. Well, the journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step. One thing led to another and they came to play several gigs at Groupie, a club on Malmskillnadsgatan in the center of Stockholm. In those days Malmskillnadsgatan was best known for its prostitutes. The life span for Neon Rose was short, but they were productive and managed to release three albums in two years. Neon Rose signed with no less than Vertigo Records in 1974. The band was exited, but it wasn't a sweet record deal. The band percentage of the record sales was ridiculously small and the promotion activities non-existent. For example, Neon Rose never went on a proper tour under their own name. They toured on weekends and without much help. Their booking company, specialized in dansband music, actually booked them to play at dance palaces, like Baldakinen in Uppsala. Not a perfect match. The dansband lovers used to shout "turn it down". And they were absolutely right. Neon Rose played loud on their 100 W Marshall amplifiers. They learned how to by-pass the decibel meter, which would have cut the power. Neon Rose became opening acts for established bands as Dr. Hook & the Medicine Show and Nazareth when they toured in Scandinavia. In contrast to weekend touring under unglamourous conditions, the band got a taste of how life might have been, staying on hotels with breakfast buffets. In the case of Nazareth, Neon Rose maybe unintentionally broke the golden rule for an opening act. Never outshine the headliner. However, the tour went well and there were no hard feelings. Actually, Gunnar Hallin was offered to replace Manny Charlton (guitarist in Nazareth). He declined. Neon Rose split up in December 1975. Some band members continued with music in an anonymous existence backing Swedish artists, while others pursued a "civilian career". The driving force Piero Mengarelli tried to revive the band twice (in 1977 and 2015). However, a reunion of the classic line-up isn't possible. Stanley Larsson and Benno Mengarelli passed away in 2007 and 2019, respectively.  


Neon RoseThe debut album, "A Dream of Glory and Pride", was released in 1974, and was followed with a sophomore release, "Two", early in 1975. Following the recording of this album, drummer Stanley Larsson left the band (for the third time) and was replaced by Thomas Wiklund. The debut album was recorded in only three weeks on eight channels. It was recorded in December 1973 at Decibel Studios, a classic recording studio situated near Slussen, Stockholm by Anders Oredsson. The ideal at the time was to achieve a laboratory sound. Tape and foam rubber were applied everywhere to get rid of so much resonance as possible, which led to a numb and artificial studio sound. There was also a statement on the back cover: "This is another album without synthesizer." The album sold about 9 000 copies. The record company was eager to follow up the debut album. The band never got time to rehearse the new songs or try them out live. The album was created under pressure. The unimaginative title, "Two", says it all. The band were not ready to release a new album. But, the album was recorded on 16 channels. Apparently, the band was moving up in the world of recording studios. It was recorded at Ljudkopia Musikstudio, Stockholm by Anders Oredsson. The album sold about 10 000 copies. The conditions were far better during the recording of their third album, "Reload". It was recorded at Marcus Music, Solna, Sweden in July and August 1975 by producer, technician and engineer Leif Mases. The band had a good material and also had time to play them live. If the two first albums were somewhat underproduced, the third album was maybe a litte bit overproduced. Piero Mengarelli later found a recording that was made after half way through the recording sessions. In his opinion, some additional choirs and vocals was all that was missing. Then "Reload" would have been a fantastic album. Their first two album covers are stylish, but the "Reload" album cover created by Anders F. Rönnblom is absolutely hideous and an early product placement for Adidas sneakers. The third album was recorded on 24 channels and sold about 10 000 copies. A fourth album was planned with Manny Charlton as producer. Words never became deeds. All in all, Neon Rose sold about 30 000 copies. Today, international buyers are willing pay top dollar for their vinyl albums in good shape. All albums were re-relased on cd in 2005 with bonus tracks. Of course, I got all three. Now and then, I listen to them with great pleasure. All three albums stand the test of time. 
 

Neon Rose
Neon Rose effectively combined somber vocals, hard guitar riffs, pulsating basslines and pounding drums. They would have become more famous if they had managed to stay together and just kept going. Stanley Larsson quit no less than three times. He later told singer Roger Holegård (quit two times) that leaving Neon Rose was the biggest mistake of his life. Obviously, the timing wasn't perfect. In those days, playing hard rock music, singing in English and having an attitude was to stand out and to stand alone. The counterreaction was not long in coming. The radical music journalist Tomas Tengby wrote a review with the headline "Neon Rose - a product" in the influential left-wing music journal "Musikens Makt" (The Power of Music). The zeitgeist was hostile with little or no tolerance for individualism or commercialism. In a follow-up article the journal claimed that "Neon Rose denies their origin". Unadulterated nationalism from the left, an opinion which you today would expect from the far-right. The once so radical Tomas Tengby ended up his career in TV cooking programs on senior citizen-friendly broadcasting hours. This serves him right. A second explanation to why the band didn't break big was that the record company didn't promote them, which is incomprehensible considering that record companies wants to make money. It was amateurish and cheap. The record company didn't even provide them with money to buy guitar strings. Instead, they were offered fancy meals at restaurants. The latter was a tax deductible activity. A third explanation to the lack of success was that there existed a work permit agreement that prevented Swedish bands from playing in England and the USA, while foreign bands could tour and play in Sweden without any restrictions. Neon Rose was virtually unknown outside Sweden. And fourth and maybe most important, internal musical differences led to strain, conflict and quitting. The setbacks were many and varied. Their final gig was at Jarlateatern, Stockholm on December 4th 1975. The band didn’t go quietly into the night. They played loud. The dream of glory and pride became just a dream. And the grading? A for effort, C for attainment. 


"Are cds the new NFT?"

Spotify intheredAR2020CD sales peaked in 2000. Thereafter, cd sales began to decrease. First gradually, then rapidly. Today, very few cds are manufactured and sold. In fact, new cds never enter the second hand market. There is no first owner. For some morbid reason I follow the statistics from the Swedish branch of the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI). The revenues from CD sales in 2021 amounted to 3 percent of total revenues. In 2021, cd sales actually increased (but from a very low level). What about the future for our beloved cd? Maybe, it will come down to greed, exlusivity and vanity. A single cd, impossible to copy and sold to the highest bidder, like NFT? Non-fungible tokens (NFT), are unique files that live on a blockchain and are able to verify ownership of a work of digital art. The hype-driven and, to say the least, environmentally unfriendly technology have found its way into the music business. Could we merge the NFT and cd technology? NFTs cannot be replicated and are unique digital assets. CDs can be copied. The CCCD system, a copy prevention system, used from 2001 until 2006 on several digital audio disc releases by EMI and Sony failed. Copy controlled cds are both dumb and inefficient, just like the "Home Taping Is Killing Music" campaign in the beginning of the 1980s, read more here (opens in a new window). The CCCD technique had huge flaws. The cds didn't play on ordinary cd players. It also compromised the sound (popped and clicked). The copy protection increased errors and the jitter rate. The cds were defective and fraudulent. The copy-protection could easily be by-passed. Could it be done in a better way today? The technology has certainly changed in 20 years. Maybe, copy protection could be revived. He who dies alone surrounded with unique and verified tokens wins.    


"Available while supplies last"

Spotify intheredAR2020Apple discontinues iPod Touch. This new, but not at all surprising, information was well hidden in flowery words from Greg Joswiak, senior vice president of Worldwide Marketing at Apple. "Today, the spirit of iPod lives on. We’ve integrated an incredible music experience across all of our products, from the iPhone to the Apple Watch to HomePod mini, and across Mac, iPad, and Apple TV... Customers can purchase iPod touch through apple.com, Apple Store locations, and Apple Authorized Resellers while supplies last." The news left me with a conundrum. Should I buy a "new" iPod or not? The seventh-generation iPod Touch was introduced in 2019 running iOS version 12.3. And because technology is moving rapidly, things become obsolete quickly. According to Apple, "products are considered obsolete when Apple stopped distributing them for sale more than seven years ago." This means that Apple no longer offers any service or repairs for these products. Well, then I'm obsolete on the verge of obsolescence. My iPod Touch is third-generation. I bought it in 2009 and it still functions after carefree and careless handling. The iPod even survived an update of new software (iOS version 5.1.1.) a couple of years ago. One by one the apps have ceased to work. I couldn't care less. I'm only interested in the Itunes app, which is Apple's most hated app. To fully master the computer-device interaction a civil engineer degree is required. Many people think that iPod is unnecessary. Why would you want a device that plays music when you could have a device that plays music and is also, a phone? Well, the iPod is less expensive than the cheapest iPhone. Moreover, the cult followers like it because it isn't a phone, which ensures distraction-free listening. The iPod Touch is now officially discontinued. So, what is the right thing to do here? One option is to go down with the ship. Sooner or later, my iPod will refuse to transfer files, no longer play or the battery won't charge. When that happens is anyone's guess. Another option, is to future-proof oneself and buy a "new" seventh-generation iPod. Buying a device that has been discontinued at a high price doesn't seem like a good idea. The price of an iPod Touch with 32, 128 and 256 GB storage is 199, 299 and 399 dollars, respectively. Not exactly cheap. But, "while supplies last" usually means clearance sale. Discontinued products tend to fall in price. But, low price or lowering prices has never been a part of Apple’s pricing strategy. It relies on product differentiation and creating a demand for its products. Together with brand loyalty, this allows the Apple to have power over their pricing. Long may you run, iPod Touch third-generation 64 GB.    
 

Before After Before